CIRCUS SENDS KIDS THE WRONG MESSAGE ABOUT ANIMALS

August 18th, 2010

Opinion: The circus sends kids the wrong message about animals
By Sujatha Ramakrishna
Special to the Mercury News
Posted: 08/10/2010 12:01:00 AM PDT

The circus is coming to town — in Oakland this week, and in San Jose next. For parents who want their children to experience the best of everything in life, the spectacle of wild animals performing amazing tricks seems like thrilling family entertainment. However, attending these events has subtle effects on children that parents should consider.
As a psychiatrist specializing in child development, I have observed directly the relationship between how children treat animals and the way that they eventually treat people. Children who abuse animals are much more likely to be aggressive toward humans. When they become teenagers, they often experience behavioral problems at home and school. As adults, they continue to display violent tendencies and may engage in criminal activities.
When parents take their children to the circus, they indirectly send them the message that animals are objects to be used, and that it is OK to ignore any pain and suffering that the animals might be experiencing. These children may grow up lacking empathy, or the ability to understand the feelings of others. If they are unable to recognize when someone else is in distress, they will have difficulties getting along with people.
On the other hand, children who are taught to treat animals with dignity and respect will also learn to treat humans in this manner, considering the needs of others as well as their own. The development of empathy and the ability to work collaboratively in social settings are key components of emotional intelligence, proved by research studies to be vital for success in school, the workplace, and personal relationships.

Animals such as tigers and elephants are not willing participants in circuses. Unlike domesticated animals, they have not been bred to work and live with humans. On occasion, they have suddenly run amok and attacked spectators. Trainers must utilize whips, chains and hooks to control them. Wild animals that stand on their heads and jump through hoops are performing unnatural acts, under the threat of force.
Children who watch these performances learn that it is acceptable to force another living creature to do something that is stressful, and often even painful, as long as it serves the purpose of entertainment. This mindset will carry over into their relationships with people, and it will not serve them well in life.
Circuses featuring human acrobats are wonderful alternatives to animal shows, and equally delightful for children. For parents who are truly interested in teaching their children about wild animals, watching nature videos is the best option.
For example, observing a group of elephants driving away predators, caring for a youngster, or playing in the mud together is not only entertaining, it is also educational. Elephants are complex, fascinating, and intelligent creatures. They live in extended family systems, with younger generations learning survival skills and appropriate social behaviors from the older ones.
Teaching children to appreciate them for what they are will help them develop empathy and respect for all living things. When we are striving to raise socially responsible and successful citizens in our community, nothing could be more important.

SUJATHA RAMAKRISHNA, M.D., of San Jose, is a child psychologist. She wrote this article for this newspaper.

NYC INTRO 389 is now INTRO 49- a bill to prohibit the use of wild animals in entertainment

August 12th, 2010

NYC INTRO 389 is now INTRO 49- a bill to prohibit the use of wild animals in entertainment
Intro. 49 by Council Members Mendez, Brewer, Chin, Koslowitz, Mark-Viverito, Palma, Williams and Dromm

A Local Law to amend the administrative code of the city of New York, in relation to prohibiting the display of wild or exotic animals for public entertainment or amusement.

Be it enacted by the Council as follows:
Section 1. Chapter one of title 17 of the administrative code of the city of New York is amended by adding a new section 17-196 to read as follows:
§17-196. Display of Wild or Exotic Animals for Public Entertainment or Amusement a. Definitions. For purposes of this section, the following terms shall have the following meanings:
1. “Display” shall mean to undertake any exhibition, act, circus, ride, trade show, carnival, parade, race, photographic opportunity, performance or similar undertaking in which animals are required to perform tricks, fight or participate as accompaniments in performances for the amusement or benefit of an audience.
2. “Exhibition” shall mean any public showing, presenting to view, public display or exposition.
3. “Exotic animal” shall mean any and all of the following orders and families, whether bred in the wild or in captivity, and shall include any or all of their hybrids with domestic species:
i. proboscidae, including, but not limited to, elephant;
ii. cetacea, pinnipedia, sirenia and other species of sea mammals, including, but not limited to, dolphin, whale, seal, sea lion and walrus;
iii. marsupialia, including, but not limited to, tasmanian devil, dasyure, bandicoot, kangaroo, wallaby, opossum, wombat, koala bear, cuscus, numbat, pigmy, sugar and great glider;
iv. perissodactyla, including, but not limited to, rhinoceros and tapir; provided that such term shall not include the species equus caballus, including, but not limited to, horse, donkey and mule.
v. artiodactyla, including, but not limited to, deer, antelope, sheep, hippopotamus, giraffe and camel;
vi. mustelidae, including, but not limited to, skunk, weasel, otter, marten, mink, ermine, pole cat, zorille, wolverine, stoat, ferret and badger;
vii. procyonidae, including, but not limited to, raccoon, kinkajou, cocamistle, cat-bear, panda and coatimundi;
viii. edentata, including, but not limited to, sloth and armadillo;
ix. viverridae, including, but not limited to, mongoose, civet, binturong, fossa, linsang, suricate and genet;
x. all predatory or large birds, including, but not limited to, eagle, hawk, falcon, owl, vulture, condor, emu, rhea and ostrich;
xi. sciuridae;
xii. chiroptera;
xiii. all venomous insects, including, but not limited to, bee, hornet and wasp;
xiv. arachnida and chilopoda, including, but not limited to, all venomous spiders, scorpion, and all venomous arthropods;
xv. all large rodentia, including, but not limited to, gopher, muskrat, paca, woodchuck, marmot, beaver, prairie dog, capybara, sewellel, viscacha, porcupine and hutia;
xvi. hyracoidea;
xvii. pholidota;
xviii. insectivora, including, but not limited to, aardvark, anteater, shrew, otter shrew, gymnure, desman, tenrec, mole and hedge hog; and
xix. dermoptera.
4. “Person” shall mean any individual, establishment, firm, association, organization, partnership, trust, corporation or company.
5. “Wild animal” shall mean any and all of the following orders and families; provided that such term shall not include “companion animal” as such term is defined in section three hundred fifty of the New York state agriculture and markets law:
i. non-human primates and prosimians, including, but not limited to, chimpanzee and monkey;
ii. felidae and all hybrids thereof; provided that such term shall not include the species felis catus;
iii. canidae; provided that such term shall not include domesticated dogs and captive bred fennec foxes;
iv. ursidae;
v. crocodylia; and
vi. all reptiles that are venomous by nature and the following species and orders: burmese python, reticulated python, african rock python, green anaconda, yellow anaconda, australian amethystine python, indian python, asiatic monitor, nile monitor, white throat monitor, black throat monitor, crocodile monitor, komodo dragon and any hybrid thereof.
6. “Felis catus” shall mean: (i) domesticated cats, feral cats, domesticated cats that were formerly owned and that have been abandoned and that are no longer socialized, and the offspring of such cats; and (ii) hybrids of felis catus that are registered by the american cat fanciers association or the international cat association, provided that such cats shall be without any wild felid parentage for a minimum of five generations.
7. “Wildlife sanctuary” shall mean any organization as described in section 170(b)(1)(A)(vi) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, and its subsequent amendments, and that is in compliance with all applicable provisions of the Animal Welfare Act, 7 U.S.C. §§ 2131, et. seq., and operates a place of refuge where abused, neglected, unwanted, impounded, abandoned, orphaned or displaced wild animals are provided care for their lifetime or rehabilitated and released back to their natural habitat and, with respect to any animal owned by the organization, does not: (i) use any such animal for any type of entertainment, recreational or commercial purpose, except for the purpose of exhibition as defined by the New York state department of environmental conservation at section 175.2(b) of part 175 of subchapter I of chapter I of title six of the New York codes, rules and regulations; (ii) sell, trade, lend or barter such animal or the body parts of such animal; or (iii) breed such animal.
b. Prohibited acts. No person shall display or sponsor the display of a wild animal or an exotic animal within the city of New York; provided, however, that this section shall not apply to (i) any institution accredited by the American zoo and aquarium association; (ii) any institution operated by the wildlife conservation society of New York state; (iii) any veterinarian in the ordinary course of such veterinarian’s practice of business; (iv) any wildlife sanctuary; and (v) any laboratory operated pursuant to section 504 of the New York state public health law.
c. Enforcement. Any authorized employee, officer or agent of the department or any other city agency designated by the mayor shall be empowered to enforce the provisions of this section or any rule promulgated thereunder.
d. Violation and penalty. Any person who violates paragraph b of this section or any rule promulgated thereunder shall be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed one thousand dollars for each violation; provided that for a first such violation, such person may be issued a written warning in lieu of such civil penalty.
e. Rules. The commissioner of the department or the commissioner of any other city agency designated by the mayor to enforce the provisions of this section may promulgate any rules as may be necessary for the purposes of carrying out the provisions of this section.
§2. Severability. If any subsection, sentence, clause, phrase or other portion of this local law is, for any reason, declared unconstitutional or invalid, in whole or in part, by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be deemed severable and such unconstitutionality or invalidity shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this local law, which remaining portions shall remain in full force and effect.
§3. This local law shall take effect one hundred and eighty days after its enactment.

Letter to Attorney General Andrew Cuomo, RE: Cole Bros. Circus

August 5th, 2010

The Honorable Andrew Cuomo
Attorney General
Office of the Attorney General
The Capital
Albany, NY 12223-0341

August 5, 2010

Dear Attorney General Cuomo,
I am writing to you today to ask that you intervene, in the interest of the safety of New Yorker’s, and in the interest of the animals that are continually abused and mistreated by the staff and handlers of the Cole Bros. Circus.

This circus has been repeatedly cited by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) for abuse and neglect of their animals. The USDA has filed formal charges of violations of the Animal Welfare Act against Cole Bros. In the recent past, a 450 pound Cole Bros. tiger escaped in Forest Park Queens for over half an hour before it was captured. Cole Bros. elephants have killed two members of the public, injured dozens of others, and rampaged during performances. Three months ago, charges were filed with the USDA over an incident in which an elephant escaped from the Cole Bros. handlers in Lynchburg, Virginia.

Our local elected and appointed officials, specifically Councilman James Oddo, Borough President James Molinaro, and S.I.Parks Commissioner Thomas Paulo have ignored our concerns and multiple requests for intervention.

It is extremely disconcerting that prudence, due diligence, and concern for the best interests of the innocent, that being the children and the animals, did not outweigh the interest of profit in awarding Cole Bros. permits again this year.

We are all complicit in choosing to do nothing to mitigate the risk of continued abuses by the Cole Bros. Circus. Please begin an investigation into the reckless and dangerous history of the Cole Bros. Circus, and see that they are no longer able to return for performances in New York.

Thank you, and I look forward to hearing from you.

Sincerely,
John G. Hynes, DVM
USDA Accredited Veterinarian, NY

At the Cole Bros. Circus, Spectacle and Protest

July 20th, 2010

http://www.silive.com/eastshore/index.ssf/2010/07/at_the_circus_on_staten_island.html

SI LIVE COVERAGE OF COLE BROS CIRCUS AND PROTEST

July 20th, 2010

The Circus hits Staten Island

“>

The Circus hits Staten Island

DEMONSTRATION AGAINST COLE BROS. CIRCUS- VETERINARIAN CITES ABUSE OF CHILDREN AND ANIMALS

July 6th, 2010

Contact: Dr. John Hynes FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Cell: 917-626-3028
Email: jghdvmpc@yahoo.com

STATEN ISLAND VETERINARIAN TO LEAD PRESS CONFERENCE AND DEMONSTRATION AGAINST COLE BROS. CIRCUS: CITES ABUSE OF CHILDREN AND ANIMALS, AND A CLEAR AND PRESENT DANGER TO THE COMMUNITY

Cole Bros. Pedophile Clown Convicted in NY Court on 9 Counts of Sodomy, Sexual Abuse, and Endangering the Welfare of an 11 year old boy
Circus repeatedly cited by the USDA for neglect, abuse, and escape of animals in their care

This circus has been repeatedly cited by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) for abuse and neglect of their animals. The USDA has filed formal charges of violations of the Animal Welfare Act against Cole Bros. In the recent past, a 450 pound Cole Bros. tiger escaped in Forest Park Queens for over half an hour before it was captured. Cole Bros. elephants have killed two members of the public, injured dozens of others, and rampaged during performances. Three months ago, charges were filed with the USDA over an incident in which an elephant escaped from the Cole Bros. handlers in Lynchburg, Virginia. This latest incident resulted in trauma and injury to the elephant, sustained after falling downhill into a ditch.
Local elected and appointed officials, specifically Councilman James Oddo, Borough President James Molinaro, and S.I.Parks Commissioner Thomas Paulo have ignored our concerns and multiple requests for intervention.
Factsheets and Informational packets will be available to journalists and members of the media.
Location: 1110 Fr. Capodanno Blvd., Midland Beach, Staten Island

Date and Time: Monday, July 19, 2010 4:00 PM

For more information or to schedule an interview, please contact
Dr. John Hynes at the number/email above.

PRESIDENT OF CIVIC ASSOCIATION HAS “NO PROBLEM” WITH COLE BROS. CIRCUS

May 18th, 2010

(This is her response to me today, almost 2 months after I originally wrote to her)

Dear Mr. Hynes:

I short while ago i received a very heated, insulting phone call from a Mrs. *****.  How she got my office number I have no idea.  When asked she said she got it and started insulting me because of the Cole Bros. Circus.  I asked her if she was part of PETA and she said she is involved in numerous organizations.  When i told her to stop calling me at the office, she said she will call me whenever she *@#$%%^ wants and i hung up on her.

I wanted noted that i will not put up with people who apparently are with your group calling and insulting me at my place of business.  This is totally unprofessional.  As i stated to ********   a couple of months ago (which i informed her that she should not have given out my personal information because that is a no no between civics) that the Midland Beach Community never had an issue with the circus, nor have we ever received any complaints.  I am a member of community board 2 and also no complaints have been logged with the board.  I personally spoke to the Borough Parks Commissioner Thomas Paulo who also confirmed to me that there has never been a complaint logged through his office on the circus.  So there it is in a nutshell.  We have never had a problem with the Circus.  We welcome their contributions of free shows to the disabled and mentally disabled community for some happiness in their lives.  As far as the clown goes, this happened back in 1999 and conviction in 2001.  If you look through the community posts for pedophiles you will see a great number of them within the Staten Island community.  This can happen anywhere at any time.  If there were complaints against the Circus we would definitely join in but they have been coming to our community for over 20 years and not once have we heard any negativity.

Yasmin Ammirato

midbeachcivic@msn.com

President - Midland Beach Civic

“Don’t allow untrustworthy circus to perform in city parks”- Staten Island Advance, May 11, 2010

May 15th, 2010

Don’t allow untrustworthy circus to perform in city parks
By Letters to the Editor/Staten Island Adva…
May 11, 2010, 5:09AM
By Dr. JOHN G. HYNES,
NEW PROVIDENCE, N.J.

The following was sent to all members of the New York City Council:

This letter references the Cole Brothers Circus schedule that would include visits to New York City parks this summer.

I cite for you the disturbing and reckless history of Cole Brothers, including a 15-count indictment of Christopher Bayer, also known as “Smiley” (their star clown). He was convicted in a New York court in 2001 on nine counts of sodomy, sexual abuse, and child endangerment of an 11-year-old boy.

Cole Brothers has been cited by the Department of Agriculture and fined for multiple violations of the Animal Welfare Act.

Respectfully, it is at your level, that prudence, due diligence, and concern for the best interests of the innocent enter into the equation. We are all complicit if we do nothing to mitigate the risk of potential or continued abuses. Please deny any Cole Brothers request for permits to perform in city parks this summer.
[The writer, a Staten Island native, is a veterinarian who practices at The Clinic at Country Estate in Richmond Valley and South Shore Veterinary Practice in New Dorp. He is the Richmond County representative for the League of Humane Voters of New York.]

CONTACT Council Member James Oddo (he represents the district where Cole Bros is scheduled to perform) and ask him to see that permits are denied for this reckless and dangerous circus  at www.jamesoddo.com/contact/

Video of Ringling Bros Abuse of Elephants

May 15th, 2010

Visit RinglingBeatsAnimals.com“>
Visit RinglingBeatsAnimals.com

HELP STOP COLE BROS CIRCUS ON STATEN ISLAND- CONTACTS BELOW:

May 3rd, 2010

Sexual Predators and Animal Abuse in the NYC Parks

(Sent to all members of the NYC Council)

This letter references the Cole Bros. Circus schedule that would include visits to NYC Parks this summer.

I cite for you the disturbing and reckless history of Cole Bros., including a 15 count indictment of Christopher Bayer, also known as “Smiley” (their star clown). He was convicted in a NY court on 9 counts of sodomy, sexual abuse, and child endangerment of an 11 year old boy.

Cole Bros. has been cited by the USDA and fined for multiple violations of the Animal Welfare Act.

Respectfully, it is at your level, that prudence, due diligence, and concern for the best interests of the innocent enter into the equation. We are all complicit if we do nothing to mitigate the risk of potential or continued abuses. Please deny any Cole Bros. request for permits to perform in NYC Parks this summer.

Sincerely,
John G. Hynes, DVM
USDA Accredited Veterinarian, NY
Board Member, NY League of Humane Voters

Only one of 51 Council Members responded to my letter.
WHAT YOU CAN DO:
CONTACT Speaker Quinn today, and ask why the council is allowing this reckless circus to perform in our parks. She can be reached at 212-788-7210, or 212-564-7757.
CONTACT Council Member James Oddo (he represents the district where Cole Bros is scheduled to perform) at www.jamesoddo.com/contact/